Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Renault 2010 (merged)
The AUTOSPORT Bulletin Board > Forums > Racing Comments
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 131, 132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138, 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146, 147, 148, 149, 150, 151, 152, 153, 154, 155, 156, 157, 158, 159, 160, 161, 162, 163, 164, 165, 166, 167, 168, 169, 170, 171, 172, 173, 174, 175, 176, 177, 178, 179, 180, 181, 182, 183, 184, 185, 186, 187, 188, 189, 190, 191, 192, 193, 194, 195, 196
F1_conman
QUOTE (swiniodzik @ Oct 29 2010, 22:47) *
Good points Gemini about Vitaly but it's been discussed to death already in here, hasn't it? If he isn't good enough yet to drive for a team as competitive as Renault but they think he could be ready one day, try to loan him to Lotus where he can learn the ropes without much pressure and get someone alongside Kubica who can help the team move forward with his results and technical feedback. And before someone comes up with the argument that Vitaly is helping the team with his sponsors - I'm the one who thinks that relying on a driver's sponsors as much as Renault is standing still and not healthy at all for a team which aims to fight at the very top.



up.gif up.gif up.gif

We need to get some of these guys and girls from there post here. This place has been so dominated by the Kubica fans and it's always nice to have some kind of an equilibrium. So far we've only had Captain Tightpants from the Antipodes supporting Petrov all the way nicely up.gif but some additional forces to balance things out a little bit here would be more than welcome!


I don't think Russians travel well on the internet (as opposed to Poles) - they tend to stick to websites with *.ru suffix. I wonder why that is?
Titov
QUOTE (Gbain @ Oct 29 2010, 19:15) *
Found this poll on Petrov's official blog:


http://vitalypetrov.ru/forum/index.php?sho...ic=34&st=40

wink.gif

Funs are funny, LOL
GrzegorzChyla
QUOTE (Muppetmad @ Oct 29 2010, 19:21) *
The best what? ohwell.gif

best Russian F1 driver.
And Robert is best Polish F1 driver.
That is for sure
TudorMiron
QUOTE (F1_conman @ Oct 29 2010, 19:45) *
I don't think Russians travel well on the internet (as opposed to Poles) - they tend to stick to websites with *.ru suffix. I wonder why that is?



Well, some of them do smile.gif

Cheers
Ted
korzeniow
QUOTE (F1_conman @ Oct 29 2010, 20:45) *
I don't think Russians travel well on the internet (as opposed to Poles) - they tend to stick to websites with *.ru suffix. I wonder why that is?


Maby that's why:


Hezz
QUOTE (Muppetmad @ Oct 29 2010, 17:21) *
The best what? ohwell.gif

Oh, and this quote sums it up perfectly:



There is a clear difference between having an opinion and being delusional.


Tell this to Robert fanboys wink.gif
korzeniow
Muppetmad
QUOTE (Hezz @ Oct 30 2010, 03:38) *
Tell this to Robert fanboys ;)


Well, I think Robert fanboys at least can justify their opinion, even if their reasoning isn't brilliant at times. I mean, just look at this post and the post two down:

http://vitalypetrov.ru/forum/index.php?sho...post&p=6082

Hey, let's not use logical reasoning, let's just use a smiley to make our point! ohwell.gif

The fact is, you can spin it any way you want, but you can't say Vitaly's currently better than Robert. You can say he has the potential to be - and that once he gains experience he could be quicker - but to say he's quicker now in my mind is simply bonkers and cannot be justified. The points count, retirement count based on driver error and podium finish count tells us why.

QUOTE (GrzegorzChyla @ Oct 29 2010, 20:22) *
best Russian F1 driver.
And Robert is best Polish F1 driver.
That is for sure


What a shocking revelation! wink.gif
korzeniow
@Muppetmad, Gezz...

What? You are offended that not everyone thinks Kubica is the best?

Most of those who voted on Vitaly obviously aren't F1 experts, the rest of them simply wanted to support their fellow countryman....
Muppetmad
QUOTE (korzeniow @ Oct 30 2010, 07:39) *
@Muppetmad, Gezz...

What? You are offended that not everyone thinks Kubica is the best?

Most of those who voted on Vitaly obviously aren't F1 experts, the rest of them simply wanted to support their fellow countryman....


I guess I'm not a nationalistic person, so I can't understand the national pride thing wink.gif . I only support British athletes when I feel they deserve my support. I generally support Canada in the winter olympics, but I think that's mostly because I just want them to beat America more than anything else lol.gif

Forgive me, I'd just woken up and that's when I'm most serious smile.gif
STRFerrari4Ever


Here's a pic I did cool.gif
Gbain
Nice... only that sign... it doesn't suit F1. Its more like Hanna Montana, don't you think?
STRFerrari4Ever
QUOTE (Gbain @ Oct 30 2010, 21:48) *
Nice... only that sign... it doesn't suit F1. Its more like Hanna Montana, don't you think?

lol.gif Yeah I guess but we have to deal with Adrian Sutil's fruitilicious pictures so I guess its okay drunk.gif
Gbain
RF1 - Interview with VP

QUOTE
Have you done any special preparation for this race?
After Korea I went straight to Enstone to see the engineers and to talk about Brazil. The team have lots of data from last year, which is useful for learning the track because you can see the gears, the braking, the line, and you can start to understand the lap more. I also went back in the simulator to help me learn the Interlagos circuit. It only takes an hour to know the track pretty well and to have the confidence to start pushing.

rolleyes.gif

I have a strange feeling someone will crash yet once more. rolleyes.gif
MrMonaco
Reminds me of a team radio quote from Canada 08' by BMW - "Ok Robert, big push now!(...) 10 laps of big push!" wink.gif

Ps. I wonder what role in this years' championship will Robert play. If we could be competitive in Brazil we could really have influence on the final results. I have a feeling that someone would hate Robert after that just like they did with Glock in 2008 drunk.gif
Lord_Shaitan
QUOTE (MrMonaco @ Nov 2 2010, 12:35) *
Reminds me of a team radio quote from Canada 08' by BMW - "Ok Robert, big push now!(...) 10 laps of big push!" ;)

Ps. I wonder what role in this years' championship will Robert play. If we could be competitive in Brazil we could really have influence on the final results. I have a feeling that someone would hate Robert after that just like they did with Glock in 2008 drunk.gif

You don't remember why Vettel overtook Lewis and almost trashed his championship? I'll remind you tongue.gif . It was just because of Robert. Everybody were talking about Glock cuz he lost his position to Lewis. If he didn't then I think Robert would be a scapegoat IMO(he was lapped and overtook Hamilton).
MrMonaco
Oh I remember pretty well how Robert was smashed ("why the hell he was unlapping himself?!") but it was overshadowed by the bashing of Glock from the opposite camp wink.gif
wingwalker
QUOTE (Lord_Shaitan @ Nov 2 2010, 13:00) *
You don't remember why Vettel overtook Lewis and almost trashed his championship? I'll remind you tongue.gif . It was just because of Robert. Everybody were talking about Glock cuz he lost his position to Lewis. If he didn't then I think Robert would be a scapegoat IMO(he was lapped and overtook Hamilton).



Planet F1 were calling for a few races ban for RK for that lol.gif
Gbain
So, what is the "worst" thing KUB can do? Besides kamikaze attack, off course, but that is more likely something Petrov could accomplish... ohwell.gif
KUB could overtake BUT on last few laps and taking away from him mathematical chances to defend WDC? Or he could finish just behind ALO making everybody behind a bit itchy? tongue.gif
Measuring by the level of his cautiousness and pessimism in predictions, he should finish quite strong here. He will have fresh engine and good F-duck. Another podium possible?
Muppetmad
QUOTE (wingwalker @ Nov 2 2010, 12:52) *
Planet F1 were calling for a few races ban for RK for that lol.gif


If true, that was very stupid. You have every right to unlap yourself if you can do so, and frankly Robert overtaking Hamilton just showed how slow the McLaren was and how inept at overtaking Vettel was (and potentially still is). The fact is, Robert was fighting for 3rd place in the championship and a few slow moving cars up ahead could have gotten him the extra point he needed. Staying behind Hamilton would have compromised that - whether he's a title contender or not is out of the question.
fat.monkey
QUOTE (Gbain @ Nov 2 2010, 09:19) *
[snipped]RK[/snipped] He will have fresh engine and good F-duck. Another podium possible?


yes, please.
merci beaucoup.
Lord_Shaitan
QUOTE (Muppetmad @ Nov 2 2010, 16:36) *
If true, that was very stupid. You have every right to unlap yourself if you can do so, and frankly Robert overtaking Hamilton just showed how slow the McLaren was and how inept at overtaking Vettel was (and potentially still is). The fact is, Robert was fighting for 3rd place in the championship and a few slow moving cars up ahead could have gotten him the extra point he needed. Staying behind Hamilton would have compromised that - whether he's a title contender or not is out of the question.

Planet F1 have changed their approach to Robert about 180 degree wink.gif . They used to trash him every time they could. That was funny sometimes tongue.gif ...
Muppetmad
QUOTE (Lord_Shaitan @ Nov 2 2010, 15:59) *
Planet F1 have changed their approach to Robert about 180 degree ;) . They used to trash him every time they could. That was funny sometimes tongue.gif ...


Yes, I have noticed they're much less critical now.
MrMonaco
QUOTE (Gbain @ Nov 2 2010, 15:19) *
So, what is the "worst" thing KUB can do? Besides kamikaze attack, off course, but that is more likely something Petrov could accomplish... ohwell.gif
KUB could overtake BUT on last few laps and taking away from him mathematical chances to defend WDC? Or he could finish just behind ALO making everybody behind a bit itchy? tongue.gif
Measuring by the level of his cautiousness and pessimism in predictions, he should finish quite strong here. He will have fresh engine and good F-duck. Another podium possible?

Maybe a wasn't clear enough but I'm really looking forward for a good performance from Robert and this would inevitably make an influence on championship wink.gif
thuGG
Hmm, interesting: http://joesaward.wordpress.com/2010/10/27/...nault-f1-story/
Gbain
QUOTE (MrMonaco @ Nov 2 2010, 17:09) *
Maybe a wasn't clear enough but I'm really looking forward for a good performance from Robert and this would inevitably make an influence on championship wink.gif

up.gif Same here. Its time for some good luck and not just solid performance from Robert bad luck and stupid mistakes notwithstanding.
alecc
QUOTE (thuGG @ Nov 2 2010, 17:13) *


Interesting indeed, Renault F1 rebranded as "Team Lotus"?
Gbain
QUOTE (alecc @ Nov 2 2010, 17:29) *
Interesting indeed, Renault F1 rebranded as "Team Lotus"?


It all sounds very complicated and hypothetical. One question should be answered: why on earth would Renault sell its engines to Fernandes if their team (RF1) is fighting with the same Fernandes for rights over Lotus brand?
Gemini
Kings, Sultans...

Who next? Wizards, hobbits and elfs?... opps, sorry... Elf is already there ;-)
Gemini
another take on the story...

http://www.autosport.com/features/article.php/id/3152

alecc
QUOTE (Gemini @ Nov 2 2010, 19:04) *
Kings, Sultans...

Who next? Wizards, hobbits and elfs?... opps, sorry... Elf is already there ;-)


lol.gif lol.gif
Roni
QUOTE (Gemini @ Nov 2 2010, 19:04) *
Kings, Sultans...

Who next? Wizards, hobbits and elfs?... opps, sorry... Elf is already there ;-)

You mean elves?
Nustang70
QUOTE (Gbain @ Nov 2 2010, 16:40) *
It all sounds very complicated and hypothetical. One question should be answered: why on earth would Renault sell its engines to Fernandes if their team (RF1) is fighting with the same Fernandes for rights over Lotus brand?



And more questions: How can Group Lotus afford to purchase an F1 team outright? And how do they expect to continue to fund the team? Fernandes' experiment with the Lotus name this year indicates that the brand alone isn't strong enough to attract a strong portfolio of sponsors...
sir jackie walker
QUOTE (Gbain @ Nov 2 2010, 19:40) *
It all sounds very complicated and hypothetical. One question should be answered: why on earth would Renault sell its engines to Fernandes if their team (RF1) is fighting with the same Fernandes for rights over Lotus brand?


Let us not forget that Renault F1 engine division in Viry is nowadays separate from Renault F1 Team in Enstone. I think Renault the car company (controlling F1 engine maker) would rather supply Red Bull, Renault the F1 team, and Team Lotus, than Red Bull, Lotus, and 1Malaysia/Air Asia.
korzeniow
QUOTE (sir jackie walker @ Nov 3 2010, 09:57) *
Let us not forget that Renault F1 engine division in Viry is nowadays separate from Renault F1 Team in Enstone. I think Renault the car company (controlling F1 engine maker) would rather supply Red Bull, Renault the F1 team, and Team Lotus, than Red Bull, Lotus, and 1Malaysia/Air Asia.


Yes, maby they would, but they haven't anything to say in this case since it's not their team
MrMonaco
If they (Renault Co.) loaned money to GenII it's not that simple. The teams situation is pretty complicated as Joe Saward indicates recently.
korzeniow
QUOTE (MrMonaco @ Nov 3 2010, 11:32) *
If they (Renault Co.) loaned money to GenII it's not that simple. The teams situation is pretty complicated as Joe Saward indicates recently.


It is simple, because that's where Snoras comes to the play.
MrMonaco
I think it's still a matter of will. In long term Renault is surely looking for a way out of F1 but do you really think they are going to make it before the currnet CA expire? It's obvious that Renault choose a smart way of getting out, cutting fundings and yet still having a "Renault F1" on the grid but I still think they would prefer to supply RB, Lotus and Renault.
sir jackie walker
QUOTE (korzeniow @ Nov 3 2010, 13:27) *
Yes, maby they would, but they haven't anything to say in this case since it's not their team


But that's the point I thought myself to have made: it's not their team anymore, but the engines are still theirs. The post I quoted questioned why Renault would supply engines to Fernandes, while Renault F1 are possibly (grain, salt, other nutrition...) aspiring to become Lotus themselves. I didn't mean they could block Lopez from changing the name, merely tried to point out Renault would probably rather see Renault F1 stay Renault for some time, and therefore would have no reason not to supply Fernandes' team.
korzeniow
QUOTE (MrMonaco @ Nov 3 2010, 12:29) *
I think it's still a matter of will. In long term Renault is surely looking for a way out of F1 but do you really think they are going to make it before the currnet CA expire? It's obvious that Renault choose a smart way of getting out, cutting fundings and yet still having a "Renault F1" on the grid but I still think they would prefer to supply RB, Lotus and Renault.


Renault sold its team. CA doesn't affect Renault, it affects only team owner Genii. Renault got out of CA already.

And I have to repeat myself: it's not the case what Renault preffers, because it's not Renault's team.
SRK
QUOTE (thuGG @ Nov 2 2010, 17:13) *


lol.gif

Renault have quarter (very little? Mercedes have 'only' 45,1% 'Mercedes GP') Renault F1 Team-Whiteways Technical Center in Enstone, contract with Genii that binds both parties in the coming years (funding, name, ownership structure etc. it's no fun)... and engine supply contract with the 1Malaysia, who is in a state of war with Lotus Group... Business Renault, Genii and Lotus Group? I don't think so. Antagonism of interests.
CaptainJackSparrow
At the end of the day, the facilities, the staff etc, they don't change. If Renault is 100% owned by Renault or 25% or even 1%, these are just shares on a piece of paper, nothing in the real world changes, it's still the same outfit. So to me, Renault is still 100% 'Renault'.

Gemini
QUOTE (CaptainJackSparrow @ Nov 3 2010, 17:50) *
At the end of the day, the facilities, the staff etc, they don't change. If Renault is 100% owned by Renault or 25% or even 1%, these are just shares on a piece of paper, nothing in the real world changes, it's still the same outfit. So to me, Renault is still 100% 'Renault'.


They do change... with shrinking budget. Without cash flow, all you mention is... museum.
FigJam
Exactly. This team is basically an underfunded operation at best now, unless things change I can't see them ever being a strong, front running team like the old days of Renault.

Treading water currently. Lucky the 2010 car was a good one, next year will be a litmus test.
korzeniow
Hell freezed over. I agree with FIGJAM ....
Lord_Shaitan
QUOTE (korzeniow @ Nov 4 2010, 08:48) *
Hell freezed over. I agree with FIGJAM ....

lol.gif
korzeniow
So, Brazlian GP starts from today. Pretty quiet here. Unfortunatelly rain is predicted for Saturday ... I just hope it won't happen.

Better R30 gets tyres up to temperature this weekend ...
Gemini
QUOTE (korzeniow @ Nov 4 2010, 10:14) *
So, Brazlian GP starts from today. Pretty quiet here.


Only 6:35 am in San Paulo now :-)

Gbain
QUOTE (Gemini @ Nov 4 2010, 10:35) *
Only 6:35 am in San Paulo now :-)

Korzeniow must be an early riser.
korzeniow
he he funny
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2012 Invision Power Services, Inc.